Ratio Decidendi
Food safety offences are strict liability. The presence of extraneous matter (a caterpillar in a tin of peas) constitutes an offence regardless of the manufacturer's care, subject to the statutory defences.
Fapte
A consumer found a caterpillar in a tin of peas manufactured by Smedleys. The company was prosecuted despite having extensive quality control procedures.
Rezumatul hotărârii
The House of Lords held that the offence was committed regardless of the company's care. However, the statutory defence was available where all reasonable precautions had been taken.
Citate cheie
"The Act imposes strict liability for food safety offences, subject to the statutory defences."
— Lord Hailsham
Tratament ulterior
Applied
Applied in subsequent food contamination prosecutions.