免责声明:本网站不构成法律建议。法律法规和判例法会发生变化。请务必就您的具体情况咨询合格的律师。

所有案例
Conflict of Laws
House of Lords
1987

Spiliada Maritime Corp v Cansulex Ltd

[1987] AC 460

判决理由

A stay of proceedings on grounds of forum non conveniens should be granted where there is another forum which is clearly more appropriate for the trial of the action.

事实

A dispute arose over damage to a vessel caused by a cargo of sulphur. Proceedings were issued in England but the defendants argued that British Columbia was the more appropriate forum.

判决摘要

The House of Lords established a two-stage test: (1) is there another forum which is clearly more appropriate? (2) if so, would the claimant be deprived of a legitimate personal or juridical advantage?

关键引述

"The burden is on the defendant to show that there is another forum which is clearly more appropriate."

Lord Goff

后续处理

Leading Authority

The definitive English authority on forum non conveniens.