The Magistrates' Court
How magistrates' courts work: summary and either-way offences, bail, sentencing powers, and appealing to the Crown Court.
Introduction
All criminal cases in England and Wales start in a magistrates' court, where cases are heard by two or three lay magistrates or by a district judge — never a jury. The court tries 'summary offences' (most motoring offences, minor criminal damage, common assault) and can deal with 'either-way' offences such as burglary and drugs offences, while the most serious 'indictable-only' crimes (murder, rape, robbery) are always sent to the Crown Court. Magistrates decide bail, and their sentencing powers are capped by the Sentencing Act 2020 at 6 months' imprisonment for a summary offence and 12 months for an either-way offence, alongside fines, community sentences and bans. A defendant convicted or sentenced by magistrates can appeal to the Crown Court, usually within 15 working days of sentence.
In Brief
Every criminal case starts in the magistrates' court, decided by 2–3 magistrates or a district judge with no jury. The court tries summary offences, can deal with either-way offences (up to 12 months' custody; 6 months for a summary offence), and sends murder, rape and robbery to the Crown Court. Appeal conviction or sentence to the Crown Court within 15 working days of sentence.
Core Principles
Starting Point of All Prosecutions — All criminal cases start in a magistrates' court. Cases are heard by either 2 or 3 magistrates or a district judge; there is no jury (GOV.UK).
Summary Offences — The court normally handles summary offences such as most motoring offences, minor criminal damage, and common assault not causing significant injury.
Either-Way Offences — More serious offences such as burglary and drugs offences are 'either way' and can be heard either in a magistrates' court or the Crown Court, depending on allocation and the defendant's election.
Indictable-Only Offences — Magistrates' courts always pass the most serious crimes — murder, rape, robbery — to the Crown Court.
Bail and Custody — The court decides whether a defendant is kept in custody or released on bail, with conditions such as staying away from certain people or places, staying indoors or wearing a tag; failing to attend after being granted bail can itself lead to prison (Bail Act 1976 framework).
Sentencing Powers — Magistrates can impose up to 6 months' imprisonment for a summary offence and up to 12 months for an either-way offence (Sentencing Act 2020, s.224(1A)), plus fines, community sentences (such as unpaid work), disqualifications and combinations of punishments.
Open and Impartial Justice — Justice 'should not only be done, but should manifestly and undoubtedly be seen to be done' — the foundational principle of magistrates' justice from R v Sussex Justices, ex parte McCarthy.
Appeals — A defendant can appeal conviction and/or sentence to the Crown Court, usually within 15 working days of being sentenced; the Crown Court rehears the case, and the sentence can go down — or change — on appeal.
Key Statutes
Magistrates' Courts Act 1980
Sentencing Act 2020
Bail Act 1976
Courts Act 2003
Leading Cases
R v Sussex Justices, ex parte McCarthy
[1924] 1 KB 256
R v Horseferry Road Magistrates' Court, ex parte Bennett
[1994] 1 AC 42
Common Scenarios
Charged with common assault
Common assault (not causing significant injury) is a summary offence tried in the magistrates' court before magistrates or a district judge without a jury. If convicted, the maximum custodial sentence the court can impose for a summary offence is 6 months, though a fine, community sentence or discharge is far more common.
Either-way charge: magistrates or Crown Court?
For an either-way offence such as burglary, the magistrates decide whether their sentencing powers (up to 12 months for an either-way offence) are sufficient. If they accept jurisdiction, the defendant can still elect Crown Court trial by jury; if the case is too serious, it is sent to the Crown Court for trial or sentence.
Convicted and want to challenge the outcome
Appeal to the Crown Court, usually within 15 working days of the date you were sentenced (an appeal out of time needs an explanation and the court's permission). The Crown Court rehears the case; it can allow the appeal, or your original sentence or conviction might change, and the court might order some of your legal costs to be paid back if you succeed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a jury in the magistrates' court?
No. Cases are decided by 2 or 3 lay magistrates or by a single district judge, who decide both guilt and sentence. Jury trial is only available in the Crown Court — which a defendant charged with an either-way offence can elect.
What is the maximum sentence magistrates can give?
Up to 6 months' imprisonment for a summary offence and up to 12 months for an either-way offence (Sentencing Act 2020, s.224(1A) — the 12-month either-way limit has applied since November 2024). The court can also impose fines, community sentences such as unpaid work, bans (for example from driving), and combinations of punishments. Cases needing more are sent to the Crown Court.
How do I appeal a magistrates' court conviction or sentence?
You appeal to the Crown Court, usually within 15 working days of the date you were sentenced. If you appeal later you must explain the delay and the court decides whether to allow it. The Crown Court rehears the case — be aware your original sentence or conviction might change, and costs orders are possible either way.
Will I get bail while my case is ongoing?
The magistrates' court decides whether you are kept in custody until your next hearing or released on bail — for example where another hearing is needed, more information is required before sentencing, or the case is passed to the Crown Court. Bail can carry strict conditions (staying away from people or places, curfews, tags), and not attending court after being granted bail can put you in prison.
Important Deadlines
Typical Costs
Official Resources
What To Do Next
Step-by-Step Guides
Know Your Rights
Common Scenarios
Get Professional Help
Part of our Police, Crime and Victims hub
Arrest rights, bail, court process, victim routes, criminal injuries compensation, and police complaints.