Case Law
Explore comprehensive overviews of every major area of English law, with key statutes, leading cases, and plain English summaries.
R (SSE Generation Ltd) v Gas and Electricity Markets Authority
Ofgem's decisions on the methodology for allocating transmission charges are subject to judicial review on conventional public law grounds, but the court will respect the regulator's specialist expertise in technical…
R (Friends of the Earth) v Secretary of State for BEIS (Net Zero Strategy)
A Secretary of State discharging the duty in section 13(1) of the Climate Change Act 2008 to prepare proposals and policies for meeting carbon budgets need not be satisfied by quantitative analysis alone, but must be…
R (Entain Group) v Gambling Commission
The Gambling Commission has power to impose substantial penalties for regulatory breaches, and such penalties will be upheld if they are proportionate to the seriousness of the breaches and the operator's culpability.
Cornerstone Telecommunications Infrastructure Ltd v Compton Beauchamp Estates Ltd
Under the Electronic Communications Code (Schedule 3A Communications Act 2003), the consideration (rent) for an agreement to install telecoms apparatus should be assessed on a 'no-network' basis — excluding the value…
Uber BV v Aslam
Uber drivers are 'workers' within the meaning of the Employment Rights Act 1996, the Working Time Regulations, and the National Minimum Wage Act. The written contractual terms stating drivers were self-employed…
Begum v Secretary of State for the Home Department
The courts should not substitute their own view for that of the Secretary of State on matters of national security. Where citizenship deprivation engages national security considerations, judicial review is limited to…
Manchester Building Society v Grant Thornton UK LLP
In professional negligence claims, the scope of the defendant's duty of care determines which losses are recoverable. The court must identify the purpose for which the advice was given and ask whether the loss that…
R (SC, CB and 8 children) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
The two-child limit on the child element of Universal Credit and Child Tax Credit does not violate Article 14 ECHR or Article 3 UNCRC. The 'manifestly without reasonable foundation' test applies to welfare benefit…
FCA v Arch Insurance (UK) Ltd
Business interruption insurance policies that cover losses arising from notifiable diseases or government-mandated closures may cover losses caused by COVID-19, depending on the policy wording. The 'but for' test of…
R (ClientEarth) v Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy
The Secretary of State's net zero strategy must contain policies that are sufficient to enable the legally binding carbon budgets to be met. The court can review whether the Government's climate policies are adequate to…
Lloyd v Google LLC
Damages under the Data Protection Act 1998 require proof of material damage or distress suffered by each individual claimant. 'Loss of control' over personal data does not, without more, give rise to a claim for…
R (on the application of Maughan) v HM Senior Coroner for Oxfordshire
The standard of proof for all conclusions at an inquest, including short-form conclusions such as suicide and unlawful killing, is the civil standard (balance of probabilities), not the criminal standard (beyond…
Williamson v Bishop of London
Clergy discipline decisions under the Clergy Discipline Measure 2003 are amenable to judicial review where procedural unfairness or error of law is alleged, though the court will give appropriate respect to the…
R (Friends of the Earth) v Secretary of State for Transport (Heathrow Third Runway)
When designating a National Policy Statement, the Secretary of State was not legally obliged to take into account the Paris Agreement targets on climate change where Parliament had not enacted those obligations into…
Enka Insaat Ve Sanayi AS v OOO Insurance Company Chubb
The law applicable to an arbitration agreement is determined by: (1) express choice; (2) implied choice; or (3) the system of law most closely connected. Where the main contract contains a choice of law clause, there is…
Dill v Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government
Inclusion of an item in the statutory list is not conclusive of its status as a 'building': a listed building must be both a building and included in the list, so on a listed building enforcement appeal under section 39…
R (Samuel Smith Old Brewery (Tadcaster)) v North Yorkshire County Council
The “openness” of the Green Belt in para 90 of the NPPF is a broad policy concept, the counterpart of urban sprawl, and is not necessarily a statement about the visual qualities of the land. Neither the Town and Country…
R (Miller) v The Prime Minister (Cherry/Miller No 2)
The Prime Minister's advice to the Queen to prorogue Parliament for five weeks was justiciable and unlawful. Prorogation is unlawful if it has the effect of frustrating Parliament's ability to carry out its…
R (DA and DS) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
The benefit cap, which limits total household welfare payments, does not constitute unlawful discrimination against lone parents and their children under Article 14 ECHR, as the government is entitled to a wide margin…
Ocean Outdoor UK Ltd v Hammersmith and Fulham LBC
Leases of council land for commercial advertising were not services concession contracts under the Concessions Contract Regulations 2016: a concession involves the authority entrusting services it would otherwise…
Lachaux v Independent Print Ltd
The 'serious harm' requirement in s.1 Defamation Act 2013 is a factual threshold distinct from the common law presumption of damage. A claimant must prove as a fact that the statement has caused or is likely to cause…
Robinson v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police
The Caparo three-stage test is not a universal test to be applied afresh in every case of alleged negligence. Where a duty of care has already been recognised in an established category of situation, the court should…
R v Mackinlay
Election expenses for party campaigning and candidate campaigning are distinct categories. Spending on campaigning that promotes or disparages a party nationally is not necessarily candidate spending, even if it…
Owens v Owens
The court must apply the statutory test for divorce (that the respondent has behaved in such a way that the petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with them) and cannot grant a divorce simply because the…
Competition and Markets Authority v GlaxoSmithKline plc (Paroxetine)
Pay-for-delay agreements in the pharmaceutical sector, where an originator company pays generic competitors to stay out of the market, may constitute both a restriction of competition by object and an abuse of dominant…
R (Good Law Project) v Electoral Commission
A donation can also be a 'referendum expense' incurred by the donor under s.111(2) of the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000. Where money is paid directly to a supplier, by agreement with the donee…
Faraday Development Ltd v West Berkshire Council
The touchstone for whether a transaction disposing of land is a public works contract requiring procurement is whether, in substance, the agreement as a whole -- viewed at the date it is concluded -- commits the…
Lee v Ashers Baking Company
Refusing to produce a cake bearing a message supporting same-sex marriage was not direct discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation. The objection was to the message, not the customer's sexual orientation.
R v K (Modern Slavery)
Trafficking within the UK under s.4(1A)(b) of the Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc.) Act 2004 is complete once the defendant intentionally arranges or facilitates a person's travel with a view to…
Love v Government of the United States of America
The forum bar under s.19B Extradition Act 2003 can prevent extradition where a substantial measure of the criminal activity occurred in the UK and extradition would not be in the interests of justice.
R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union
The government could not use the royal prerogative to trigger Article 50 TEU and begin the UK's withdrawal from the European Union without an Act of Parliament. Since the European Communities Act 1972 had given EU law…
Ivey v Genting Casinos (UK) Ltd
The test for dishonesty in criminal and civil law is objective: the court must first ascertain the actual state of the defendant's knowledge or belief as to the facts, then determine whether the conduct was dishonest by…
R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor
The Employment Tribunals and the Employment Appeal Tribunal Fees Order 2013 was unlawful and of no effect. The fees imposed — up to £1,200 for a Type B claim (including unfair dismissal) — were unlawful at common law…
Ilott v The Blue Cross
The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 does not override testamentary freedom but allows the court to make reasonable financial provision for eligible applicants. The court must balance the…
Actavis UK Ltd v Eli Lilly & Co
Patent infringement should be assessed in two stages: (1) does the variant infringe on a normal (purposive) interpretation of the claim? (2) if not, does the variant nonetheless infringe because it varies from the…
IBM United Kingdom Ltd v Dalgleish
An employer exercising discretionary powers in relation to a pension scheme owes an implied duty of good faith (the 'Imperial duty') which prevents the employer from exercising its powers in a way that would undermine…
R v Sergeant Alexander Blackman (Marine A)
The defence of diminished responsibility applies in military law as it does in civilian law. Evidence of combat stress and adjustment disorder may reduce murder to manslaughter where it substantially impairs…
Essop v Home Office
In an indirect discrimination claim, the claimant does not need to prove why a provision, criterion, or practice (PCP) puts persons sharing a protected characteristic at a particular disadvantage — only that it does so.
Grenfell Tower Inquiry
Systemic failures in fire safety regulation, building control, and the use of combustible cladding materials contributed to the Grenfell Tower disaster. Manufacturers, certifiers, and regulators all bore responsibility.
Poshteh v Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea
The Supreme Court refused to depart from Ali v Birmingham City Council, which held that duties to the homeless under Part VII of the Housing Act 1996 do not give rise to “civil rights” engaging Article 6…
Chowdury v Greece
The state has positive obligations under Article 4 ECHR to investigate situations of potential human trafficking and forced labour, even where the victims did not initially raise formal complaints.
R (Agyarko) v Secretary of State for the Home Department
The immigration rules and Article 8 ECHR require a proper assessment of proportionality when considering whether to grant leave to remain on the basis of a private or family life established in the UK.
R v Jogee; Ruddock v The Queen
The law on accessory liability in joint enterprise was wrongly extended by R v Chan Wing-Siu [1985] AC 168 (PC) and R v Powell; R v English [1999] AC 1 (HL). Those decisions incorrectly elevated mere foresight that the…
R v Golds
For the partial defence of diminished responsibility under s 52 Coroners and Justice Act 2009, 'substantial' impairment means an impairment that is more than merely trivial — it need not be total but it must be…
Streetmap.eu Ltd v Google Inc
A dominant undertaking displaying its own mapping product prominently in search results does not necessarily constitute an abuse of dominant position where there is an objective justification related to improving the…
McDonald v McDonald
Article 8 proportionality does not provide a defence to possession proceedings brought by a private sector landlord. The statutory scheme under the Housing Act 1988, which grants a mandatory right to possession on…
R (Carmichael and Rourke) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
The 'bedroom tax' (removal of the spare room subsidy in housing benefit) is unlawful discrimination under Article 14 ECHR read with Article 8 where it fails to make allowance for a claimant's disability-related need for…
Re St Mary the Virgin, Banbury
The consistory court may grant a faculty for the removal of church pews and their replacement with chairs where this serves the church's mission, even if objectors prefer to preserve the traditional appearance.
PJS v News Group Newspapers Ltd
An injunction restraining publication of private information can be maintained even after the information has been published abroad and is widely available online, because publication in a national newspaper would cause…
Patel v Mirza
The defence of illegality does not automatically bar a claim for unjust enrichment where money was paid pursuant to an illegal agreement that was not performed. The court should consider the policies underlying the…
Johnson v Secretary of State for the Home Department
The historical bar on British citizenship by descent through unmarried fathers was discriminatory, and the common law should be developed to remove the discrimination where possible.
Versloot Dredging BV v HDI Gerling Industrie Versicherung AG (The DC Merwestone)
The fraudulent claims rule justifies forfeiture of an entire claim where the fraud is material to the insured's entitlement, but a 'collateral lie' that could not, even if believed, have improved the insured's prospects…
Kennedy v Cordia (Services) LLP
Four considerations govern the admissibility of skilled (expert) evidence: whether it will assist the court, whether the witness has the necessary knowledge and experience, whether the witness is impartial, and whether…
Impact Funding Solutions Ltd v Barrington Support Services Ltd
An exclusion in an insurance policy forms part of the definition of the scope of cover and is not to be approached with any predisposition to construe it narrowly; the contra proferentem doctrine has a role only where…
Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board
A doctor is under a duty to take reasonable care to ensure that the patient is aware of any material risks involved in any recommended treatment, and of any reasonable alternative or variant treatments. A risk is…
ParkingEye Ltd v Beavis
A parking charge of £85 for overstaying a two-hour free parking limit was not an unenforceable penalty. The charge was not extravagant or unconscionable, served a legitimate interest in managing the car park, and was…
R (on the application of ClientEarth) v Secretary of State for the Environment
The Supreme Court ordered the UK government to produce new air quality plans to comply with EU nitrogen dioxide limits. The government's failure to meet binding air quality limits was unlawful and the court could…
Vidal-Hall v Google Inc
Breach of the Data Protection Act 1998 can give rise to a claim for compensation for distress alone, without requiring pecuniary loss. The misuse of private information is a tort. Service of proceedings on Google…
Mathieson v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions
Suspending disability living allowance for a severely disabled child during an extended NHS hospital stay constitutes unjustified discrimination under Article 14 ECHR read with Article 1 of Protocol 1, where the child's…
Nzolameso v Westminster City Council
When a local authority places a homeless household in accommodation outside its district, it must explain its decision-making process and the efforts made to secure accommodation within or as close to the district as…
Haile v London Borough of Waltham Forest
Whether someone “became homeless intentionally” under s.191(1) of the Housing Act 1996 is tested at the date they ceased to occupy the accommodation, as Din v Wandsworth decided, but there must also be a continuing…
R (Pham) v Secretary of State for the Home Department
Deprivation of citizenship must not render a person stateless, but the question of statelessness depends on the law of the other country of nationality, and the Secretary of State is entitled to make her own assessment…
Henia Investments Inc v Beck Interiors Ltd
A document relied upon as an Interim Application for Payment (or other payment notice) under a construction contract must be clear and unambiguous as to which payment cycle it relates to before the serious statutory and…
Coventry v Lawrence
Planning permission for an activity that generates noise does not, in itself, constitute a defence to a claim for private nuisance, nor does it change the law of nuisance so as to authorise interference with a…
P v Cheshire West and Chester Council; P and Q v Surrey County Council
A person is deprived of liberty for the purposes of Article 5 ECHR if they are under continuous supervision and control and are not free to leave, regardless of the purpose of the placement, the relative normality of…
Shergill v Khaira
The courts can adjudicate on religious disputes where they raise justiciable issues of property or civil rights. The court must identify the relevant religious doctrine and apply it neutrally, without making value…
Rendlesham Estates plc v Barr Ltd
A builder who takes on work for or in connection with the provision of a dwelling owes a duty under section 1 of the Defective Premises Act 1972 to see that the dwelling is fit for habitation when completed, and that…
Plevin v Paragon Personal Finance Ltd
The non-disclosure of a large commission on a PPI policy can make the relationship between lender and borrower unfair under s.140A Consumer Credit Act 1974, without the need to establish a common law or fiduciary duty…
Barclays Bank plc v UniCredit Bank AG
Where a contract lets one party terminate early only with the other party's consent, 'such consent to be determined by [that party] in a commercially reasonable manner', it is the manner of the determination — not…
R (Haney) v Secretary of State for Justice
Prisoners serving indeterminate sentences for public protection (IPP) have a right to have access to rehabilitative courses that would enable the Parole Board to assess whether they can safely be released. Systemic…
Huzar v Jet2.com Ltd
A technical fault with an aircraft is not an 'extraordinary circumstance' within the meaning of EU Regulation 261/2004 that would exempt the airline from paying compensation for flight delays.
Stott v Thomas Cook Tour Operators Ltd
The exclusivity rule in article 29 of the Montreal Convention bars any action for damages, however founded, arising from events on board an aircraft or in the course of embarkation or disembarkation. A claim for injury…
Kennedy v Charity Commission
The absolute exemption in section 32(2) of the Freedom of Information Act 2000, for documents held for the purposes of a statutory inquiry, is determined by the historical purpose for which the material was created or…
Barnwell Manor Wind Energy Ltd v East Northamptonshire DC
When deciding planning applications affecting the setting of a listed building, the decision-maker must give considerable importance and weight to the desirability of preserving the setting, as required by s.66 of the…
Hopkins Developments Ltd v Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Any party to a planning inquiry is entitled to know the case it has to meet and to have a reasonable opportunity to adduce evidence and make submissions on that opposing case, and procedural unfairness which materially…
Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd
The court distinguished between 'piercing the corporate veil' (treating the company and its controller as one — the concealment principle) and the 'evasion principle' (where a person interposes a company to evade or…
R v Gul
The definition of terrorism in section 1 of the Terrorism Act 2000 is wide enough to cover military attacks by non-state armed groups against armed forces in a non-international armed conflict. The breadth of the…
Re B (Children) (Care Order: Proportionality)
Adoption without parental consent (a 'non-consensual adoption') requires the court to be satisfied that nothing else will do. It is a last resort and requires a proportionality analysis under Article 8 ECHR.
R v Saunders and Others
Offenders convicted before 3 December 2012 must be sentenced under the regime in force at the date of conviction: a court is not entitled to anticipate new sentencing provisions before they come into force. For…
Pitt v Holt; Futter v Futter
A voluntary disposition can be set aside for mistake only if the mistake is sufficiently grave. It is not enough that the claimant would not have entered the transaction but for the mistake; the mistake must make it…
Superstrike Ltd v Rodrigues
A tenancy deposit that is not protected in an authorised scheme as required by sections 213–215 of the Housing Act 2004 prevents the landlord from serving a valid section 21 notice to recover possession, and the tenant…
Smith v Ministry of Defence
The UK's human rights obligations under Article 2 ECHR can apply to the deaths of soldiers in combat zones, though the operational context will be highly relevant to the assessment of what was required.
Re St Alkmund, Duffield
When considering a faculty application, the consistory court must weigh the effect of proposed works on the church's significance as a building of special architectural and historic interest against the necessity of the…
Bull v Hall
A hotel owner who refused a double room to a same-sex couple in a civil partnership committed direct discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation. The restriction was not a proportionate means of manifesting…
R v Connors
Holding another person in servitude or requiring forced labour is a serious criminal offence. The vulnerability of victims and the coercive control exercised by perpetrators are central to establishing the offence.
Al-Jedda v Secretary of State for the Home Department
Whether a deprivation order under section 40(4) of the British Nationality Act 1981 'would make a person stateless' is to be judged by that person's actual nationality status at the date the order is made; the Secretary…
R (Osborn) v Parole Board
Common law fairness requires the Parole Board to hold an oral hearing whenever fairness to the prisoner requires one. The Board must not adopt an unduly restrictive approach to directing oral hearings.
Zakrzewski v Regional Court in Lodz, Poland
An extradition warrant that was valid when issued remains valid notwithstanding later factual developments; a challenge based on errors or omissions in the particulars must be brought as an abuse-of-process argument…
R v Hughes
Under section 3ZB of the Road Traffic Act 1988 the expression “causes the death of another person by driving” requires more than the mere presence of the defendant's vehicle on the road to be struck: there must be some…
Re B-S (Children)
An application under section 47(5) of the Adoption and Children Act 2002 for leave to oppose an adoption order involves a two-stage process: has there been a change in circumstances, and if so should leave be given…
Rabone v Pennine Care NHS Foundation Trust
The operational duty under Article 2 ECHR (right to life) to take reasonable steps to protect a person from a real and immediate risk of suicide applies to voluntary psychiatric patients, not only to detained patients…
Chambers v DPP
A joke tweet threatening to blow up an airport was not 'menacing' within the meaning of s.127(1)(a) Communications Act 2003. The test is whether a reasonable person would regard the message as a genuine threat. Context…
Barr v Biffa Waste Services Ltd
The grant of a statutory environmental permit does not, without express or implied statutory authority to commit a nuisance, provide a defence to a claim in private nuisance; compliance with regulatory conditions is not…
BAA Ltd v Competition Commission
The Competition Commission's power to order divestiture of airports as a remedy for an adverse effect on competition is lawful and proportionate where the market investigation reveals structural competition concerns.
Tesco Stores Ltd v Office of Fair Trading
To establish a hub-and-spoke infringement, the OFT must prove that the retailer foresaw, or could be taken to have foreseen, that its confidential pricing information would be passed by the supplier to a competing…
Homer v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police
A requirement for a law degree for promotion to the highest grade could constitute indirect age discrimination where an older employee close to retirement could not realistically obtain the qualification. The employer…
Sugar v BBC
Information held by the BBC (or another hybrid designated public authority) is outside the scope of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 wherever it is held, even only partly, for purposes of journalism, art or…
Assange v Swedish Prosecution Authority
A public prosecutor can constitute a 'judicial authority' for the purposes of issuing a European Arrest Warrant under Part 1 of the Extradition Act 2003; the term is not restricted to a court, judge or magistrate.
Tesco Stores Ltd v Dundee City Council
Policy statements in a development plan are to be interpreted objectively, in accordance with the language used read in its proper context; their meaning is a question of law for the court, not a matter which each…
Autoclenz Ltd v Belcher
In determining employment status, the courts must identify the true agreement between the parties by examining the reality of the working relationship rather than mechanically applying the written contractual terms…
Jones v Kernott
Where a property is held in joint names by parties in a domestic relationship, there is a presumption of equal beneficial ownership but it can be displaced by evidence of a different common intention. When assessing…
R v Gnango
Where two parties voluntarily engage in a gunfight and an innocent bystander is killed by one party's shot, both can be convicted of murder. The surviving shooter is guilty as a secondary party.
R (Adams) v Secretary of State for Justice
The right to compensation for miscarriages of justice under s 133 Criminal Justice Act 1988 requires the applicant to show that a newly discovered fact shows beyond reasonable doubt that there has been a miscarriage of…
Independent Schools Council v Charity Commission
For a trust to be charitable, it must be for the public benefit. Fee-charging charities (such as independent schools) must provide more than minimal or token benefit to those who cannot afford the fees, though the…
Al-Skeini v United Kingdom
When a Contracting State exercises physical power and control over individuals during military operations abroad, it brings those individuals within its jurisdiction for the purposes of Article 1 ECHR, triggering…
R v Lyons
A member of the armed forces who claims conscientious objection remains subject to military discipline until the claim is finally determined: the services' procedure for deciding such claims satisfies Article 9(2) ECHR…
R v Blackshaw (Riots Cases)
Context is important in sentencing. Offences committed during widespread public disorder can properly attract sentences above the normal range. The courts may take into account the context of serious public disorder as…
Spread Trustee Company Ltd v Hutcheson
A trustee exemption clause that excludes liability for gross negligence, as opposed to dishonesty or wilful misconduct, is not contrary to public policy and is capable of being valid and enforceable; a later statutory…
R (Hope and Glory Public House Ltd) v City of Westminster Magistrates' Court
On an appeal from a licensing authority's decision, the magistrates' court must give appropriate weight to the licensing committee's reasons as the specialist first-instance decision-maker, and should not reverse that…
Brent LBC v Risk Management Partners Ltd
The Teckal in-house exemption is implied into the Public Contracts Regulations 2006: the Regulations do not apply to a contract between a public authority and a legally distinct entity where the authority (alone or…
R v SK
Where a defendant in criminal proceedings is or may be a victim of trafficking, the court must consider the extent to which their criminal conduct was compelled by their traffickers. The CPS should not prosecute victims…
Baker v Quantum Clothing Group Ltd
Whether a workplace is safe for the purposes of section 29(1) of the Factories Act 1961 is a relative concept, to be judged according to the general knowledge and standards of the times; foreseeability of risk is…
Jivraj v Hashwani
An arbitrator is not employed under 'a contract personally to do work' within the meaning of the Employment Equality (Religion or Belief) Regulations 2003, read in the light of Directive 2000/78/EC: although an…
Crown Prosecution Service v Piper
Where property said to be available to satisfy a confiscation order is registered in the defendant's sole name, the starting point is that equity follows the law: the beneficial interest is held by the sole registered…
Radmacher v Granatino
A pre-nuptial agreement that is freely entered into by each party with a full appreciation of its implications should be given decisive weight unless in the circumstances prevailing it would not be fair to hold the…
HJ (Iran) v Secretary of State for the Home Department
A gay asylum seeker cannot be refused asylum on the basis that they could avoid persecution by concealing their sexuality. The right to live freely and openly as a gay person is protected. The 'discretion test'…
Manchester City Council v Pinnock
Article 8 of the ECHR requires that any person at risk of being dispossessed of their home by a public authority must be able to have the proportionality of the measure determined by an independent tribunal, regardless…
R (on the application of Smith) v Secretary of State for Defence
Soldiers serving abroad on military operations remain within the jurisdiction of the UK for the purposes of Article 1 ECHR when on a UK military base, but the position is less clear for soldiers on patrol.
R (Woolas) v Parliamentary Election Court
An election may be voided under the Representation of the People Act 1983 if a candidate publishes statements about the personal character or conduct of another candidate that are false and made knowingly or recklessly.
Alstom Transport v Eurostar International Ltd
A claim for a declaration of ineffectiveness must be brought promptly. The court will consider the importance of the contract to the contracting authority and third parties when deciding whether to grant such relief.
R v Dougall
Plea agreements in which the prosecution and defence agree what the sentence should be are contrary to principle: responsibility for the sentencing decision in fraud and corruption cases rests exclusively with the…
R v Raza
The totality principle requires that when consecutive sentences are imposed, the overall sentence must be just and proportionate. The court should step back and consider whether the aggregate term is appropriate for the…
Norris v Government of the United States of America
There is no separate threshold test of exceptional circumstances for an article 8 challenge to extradition; the question is simply one of proportionality, and only the gravest effects of interference with family life…
Watkins v Woolas
Making false statements of fact about the personal character or conduct of a candidate in an election is an illegal practice under section 106 of the Representation of the People Act 1983. If proved, the election may be…
Dallah Real Estate and Tourism Holding Company v Ministry of Religious Affairs, Government of Pakistan
Where a person resists enforcement of a New York Convention award under section 103(2)(b) of the Arbitration Act 1996 on the ground that it never agreed to arbitrate, the enforcing court must make an independent…
RSPCA v Johnson
The Animal Welfare Act 2006 creates a duty of care that is objective — it is judged by whether the animal's needs are being met, not by the owner's intentions or personal circumstances. The section 9 duty applies to any…
Sturgeon v Condor Flugdienst GmbH
Passengers whose flights are subject to long delays (3 hours or more on arrival at their final destination) are entitled to compensation under EU Regulation 261/2004 on the same basis as passengers whose flights are…
Thorner v Major
Proprietary estoppel can arise from indirect assurances. It is sufficient that the claimant reasonably understood the assurances to mean they would inherit property, even if the assurances were oblique rather than…
Re Sigma Finance Corporation
Complex financial instruments must be interpreted using the same principles as other contracts — by reference to what a reasonable person with the relevant background knowledge would understand the language to mean…
R v Horncastle
The admission of hearsay evidence under the Criminal Justice Act 2003 does not necessarily violate Article 6 ECHR, even where the evidence is the sole or decisive evidence against the accused, provided there are…
Independent Trustee Services Ltd v Hope
Pension scheme trustees owe fiduciary duties analogous to but not identical with those of ordinary trustees. A pension scheme employer's power to amend the scheme is implicitly limited and cannot be exercised in a way…
Savage v South Essex Partnership NHS Foundation Trust
An NHS trust owes an operational duty under Article 2 ECHR to take reasonable steps to prevent the suicide of a detained psychiatric patient where staff know or ought to know of a real and immediate risk to life.
R v Povey
Sentencing guidelines issued by the Sentencing Guidelines Council are not a straitjacket. Judges must follow the guidelines unless it would be contrary to the interests of justice to do so, and must give reasons for…
R (James) v Secretary of State for Justice
The detention of a prisoner beyond their tariff period is only justified under Article 5(1)(a) ECHR if there remains a causal connection between the original conviction and the continued detention. The state must…
Secretary of State for the Home Department v AF (No 3)
In control order (now TPIM) proceedings, the controlled person must be given sufficient information about the allegations against them to enable them to give effective instructions to their special advocate.
DPP v Wright
“Hunts” in s.1 of the Hunting Act 2004 is used transitively of an identified quarry: hunting is by definition intentional, and merely searching for an unidentified wild mammal in order to stalk or flush it is not…
R (Weaver) v London & Quadrant Housing Trust
A registered social landlord whose allocation and management of social housing stock, including decisions to terminate a tenancy, is closely bound up with a statutory public regulatory framework is exercising a function…
Office of Fair Trading v Abbey National plc
Bank overdraft charges are part of the price or remuneration for banking services and therefore fall within the exclusion from the unfairness assessment under the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999 (now…
Re B (Children) (Care Proceedings: Standard of Proof)
The standard of proof for the facts necessary to establish the threshold conditions under section 31(2) of the Children Act 1989, and the welfare considerations under section 1, is the simple balance of probabilities…
R v Chargot Ltd (t/a Contract Services)
Under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974, once the prosecution proves that an employee was injured at work and that the employer failed to ensure their safety so far as was reasonably practicable, the burden shifts…
R v G
The offence of rape of a child under 13 (s.5 Sexual Offences Act 2003) is one of strict liability as to age. The prosecution need not prove that the defendant knew or was reckless as to the child's age. A genuine belief…
Transfield Shipping Inc v Mercator Shipping Inc (The Achilleas)
Remoteness of damage in contract may depend not just on foreseeability but also on whether the type of loss fell within the scope of the defendant's assumed responsibility. A charterer who redelivered a vessel late was…
Cobbe v Yeoman's Row Management Ltd
Proprietary estoppel cannot arise from an agreement that is expressly 'subject to contract'. In commercial contexts, sophisticated parties who knowingly proceed without binding agreement cannot claim they relied on an…
Knowsley Housing Trust v White
An assured tenancy under the Housing Act 1988 that is subject to a suspended order for possession does not come to an end when the tenant breaches the conditions of suspension; the tenant does not become a mere…
R (Corner House Research) v Director of the Serious Fraud Office
The Director of the SFO's decision to discontinue a criminal investigation on grounds of national security was lawful and within his statutory discretion under the Prosecution of Offences Act 1985.
Mosley v News Group Newspapers Ltd
A person's sexual activities carried out in private between consenting adults ordinarily carry a reasonable expectation of privacy under Article 8, and covert surveillance or publication of them requires a genuine…
R (Daniel Thwaites plc) v Wirral Magistrates' Court
A magistrates' court hearing a licensing appeal must found any restriction on the evidence relevant to the statutory licensing objectives, giving proper weight to the 'light touch' philosophy of the Licensing Act 2003…
Stack v Dowden
Where a family home is conveyed into the joint names of cohabitants without an express declaration of trust, equity follows the law and the presumption is that the beneficial interest is held jointly in equal shares…
R (Hurst) v London Northern District Coroner
Article 2 ECHR imposes a procedural obligation on the state to carry out an effective investigation into deaths where agents of the state are or may be responsible. This obligation requires an investigation that is…
R v Kennedy (No 2)
Where the victim freely and voluntarily self-injects a drug supplied by the defendant, the defendant is not guilty of manslaughter. The victim's autonomous act breaks the chain of causation.
Huang v Secretary of State for the Home Department
When deciding immigration appeals engaging Article 8 ECHR, the appellate body must decide for itself whether the refusal of leave to enter or remain is proportionate, applying the structured proportionality test rather…
Sempra Metals Ltd v Inland Revenue Commissioners
Compound interest may be awarded as a restitutionary remedy where the defendant has been unjustly enriched by the use of money over time. The previous restriction to simple interest only was overruled.
R (on the application of Laporte) v Chief Constable of Gloucestershire
Police may only take preventive action (such as stopping and turning back coaches of protesters) where a breach of the peace is imminent. The action must be proportionate and necessary. Pre-emptive action taken too far…
R (Begum) v Headteacher and Governors of Denbigh High School
The right to manifest religion under Article 9 ECHR can be lawfully restricted where the restriction is prescribed by law, pursues a legitimate aim, and is proportionate. The focus should be on whether the interference…
Miller v Miller; McFarlane v McFarlane
The three principles governing ancillary relief on divorce are: needs, compensation (for relationship-generated disadvantage), and sharing (of the fruits of the matrimonial partnership). Non-matrimonial property may be…
Argos Ltd & Littlewoods Ltd v Office of Fair Trading
Price-fixing agreements between retailers facilitated by a supplier constitute horizontal concerted practices caught by the Chapter I prohibition, even when the communication passes through a vertical hub-and-spoke…
Jones v Ministry of the Interior of Saudi Arabia
State immunity under the State Immunity Act 1978 extends to individual state officials sued in their official capacity, as well as to the state itself, and international law does not currently recognise an exception to…
Ali v Headteacher and Governors of Lord Grey School
Article 2 of the First Protocol guarantees access to the state educational system as a whole, not education at a particular school; a school exclusion that is unlawful under domestic procedural rules does not, by…
R v HTM Ltd
In a prosecution under section 2 of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974, foreseeability is relevant to whether the employer has proved under section 40 that it did all that was reasonably practicable — but only…
Barlow Clowes International Ltd v Eurotrust International Ltd
For dishonest assistance, the defendant must have knowledge of the facts making the transaction dishonest. It is not necessary that the defendant appreciated that what they were doing was dishonest by ordinary standards…
Re Spectrum Plus Ltd (in liquidation)
A charge over book debts that allows the chargor to collect and use the proceeds of the debts in the ordinary course of business, without requiring them to be paid into a blocked account, is a floating charge, not a…
R v Hasan
Duress is not available if the defendant voluntarily associated with criminals in circumstances where he ought reasonably to have foreseen compulsion by threats of violence.
Gregg v Scott
English law does not recognise a claim for loss of a chance of a better medical outcome. Where the claimant's pre-existing chance of a good outcome was less than 50%, the reduction of that chance by negligence does not…
Bradley v Jockey Club
A sports regulatory body exercising quasi-public disciplinary functions must comply with the rules of natural justice. The relationship is contractual, and the court will imply a term that the body will act fairly.
Jameel v Dow Jones & Co Inc
A defamation action can be struck out as an abuse of process where the publication is so limited that no real or substantial tort has been committed (the 'Jameel abuse' principle). The game must be worth the candle.
Siliadin v France
Article 4 ECHR (prohibition of slavery and forced labour) imposes positive obligations on states to penalise and prosecute effectively any act aimed at maintaining a person in a situation of slavery, servitude, or…
R v Goldstein; R v Rimmington
The common law crime of public nuisance requires proof of common injury to a class of the public, not merely a series of separate injuries to separate individuals; and where Parliament has created a specific statutory…
Lesotho Highlands Development Authority v Impregilo SpA
Under section 68(2)(b) of the Arbitration Act 1996 the court must ask whether the tribunal purported to exercise a power it did not have, or merely exercised erroneously a power it did have; a mere error of law…
R (Munjaz) v Mersey Care NHS Trust
The Code of Practice issued under section 118 of the Mental Health Act 1983 is guidance, not instruction: it must be given great weight and considered with great care, and a hospital may depart from it only if it has…
Amin v Brown
The common law disability of an alien enemy to sue in the English courts is part of the rules of English law relating to the traditional laws of war: it applies only where there is a war in the technical sense between…
A v Secretary of State for the Home Department (Belmarsh)
The indefinite detention without charge or trial of foreign nationals suspected of involvement in international terrorism, purportedly justified by a derogation from Article 5 ECHR, was incompatible with Articles 5 and…
Ghaidan v Godin-Mendoza
Under s.3 of the Human Rights Act 1998, the court has a broad interpretive power to read and give effect to legislation in a way that is compatible with Convention rights, even if this departs from the ordinary meaning…
Campbell v MGN Ltd
The tort of misuse of private information protects information in respect of which a person has a reasonable expectation of privacy. The court must balance the claimant's right to privacy (ECHR Article 8) against the…
R v Dica
A person who recklessly transmits a serious sexually transmitted disease (HIV) to a sexual partner, knowing they are infected and without disclosing their condition, can be convicted of inflicting grievous bodily harm…
Kirin-Amgen Inc v Hoechst Marion Roussel Ltd
Patent claims should be interpreted purposively — ascertaining what a person skilled in the art would have understood the patentee to have used the language of the claim to mean. The Protocol on Interpretation of…
Jindal Iron & Steel Co Ltd v Islamic Solidarity Shipping Co Jordan Inc (The Jordan II)
Under the Hague Rules, the carrier's obligation to properly and carefully load, handle, stow and discharge the goods cannot be delegated so as to relieve the carrier of responsibility.
R v Barnes
Consent to physical contact in sport extends to contacts that are within the rules and playing culture of the game, even if technically foul. Criminal liability arises only for conduct sufficiently grave to be…
R (Middleton) v West Somerset Coroner
Where Article 2 ECHR is engaged (deaths in state custody or involving state responsibility), an inquest must examine not just how (by what means) the deceased died, but in what circumstances, including the broader…
Halsey v Milton Keynes General NHS Trust
The court has no power to compel unwilling parties to mediate, because to do so would impose an unacceptable obstruction on their right of access to the court under Article 6 ECHR; the court's role is to encourage ADR…
HL v United Kingdom (Bournewood)
The informal admission of a compliant but incapacitated patient to a psychiatric hospital amounted to a deprivation of liberty under Article 5 ECHR, and the lack of procedural safeguards violated Article 5(4).
South Bucks District Council v Porter (No 2)
Reasons for a planning decision must be intelligible and adequate, enabling the reader to understand why the matter was decided as it was and what conclusions were reached on the principal important controversial…
Arsenal Football Club plc v Reed
Use of a registered trade mark on goods, even if perceived by the public as a badge of allegiance rather than an indication of trade origin, constitutes trade mark infringement if it affects the essential function of…
R v G and Another
The test for recklessness in criminal damage under s.1 Criminal Damage Act 1971 is subjective, not objective. The defendant must have been subjectively aware of the risk of the relevant consequence (damage to property…
Tomlinson v Congleton Borough Council
Occupiers do not owe a duty to protect people from obvious risks that they willingly accept. The social value of keeping land accessible to the public is a relevant factor. The occupier's duty under the Occupiers'…
Shogun Finance Ltd v Hudson
In a written contract, the identity of the contracting parties is determined by the written document. A rogue who fraudulently assumes another's identity to obtain goods on hire purchase does not obtain title, and the…
Transco plc v Stockport Metropolitan Borough Council
The rule in Rylands v Fletcher is a sub-species of nuisance, not a freestanding cause of action. It requires a non-natural use of land and an escape causing foreseeable damage. The rule should not be extended to cover…
Aston Cantlow PCC v Wallbank
A parochial church council is not a 'public authority' within the meaning of section 6 of the Human Rights Act 1998 when enforcing chancel repair liability, because it is not exercising functions of a public nature in…
Vento v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police
Compensation for injury to feelings in discrimination cases should be awarded in three bands: a lower band for less serious cases, a middle band for serious cases that do not merit the highest award, and an upper band…
Abbey Developments Ltd v PP Brickwork Ltd
The adjudication enforcement regime under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 requires compliance with an adjudicator's decision pending any final determination, even where there are arguable…
Marcic v Thames Water Utilities Ltd
A sewerage undertaker's duty to build additional sewer capacity is governed exclusively by the enforcement mechanism in the Water Industry Act 1991 (complaint to the regulator, then an enforcement order); the common law…
Fairchild v Glenhaven Funeral Services Ltd
Where a claimant cannot prove which of several negligent defendants caused their injury (because each materially increased the risk), the 'but for' test of causation is modified. Each defendant who materially…
Grobbelaar v News Group Newspapers Ltd
A claimant who proves defamation but whose own conduct means he has suffered no real damage may be awarded only nominal damages. The House of Lords reduced the jury award from £85,000 to £1 for a footballer who won a…
Pennington v Waine
A gift of shares may be treated as complete in equity where it would be unconscionable for the donor to recall the gift, even if the donor has not done everything in their power to transfer legal title.
Beckmann v Dynamco Whicheloe Macfarlane Ltd
Early retirement and redundancy benefits payable under an occupational pension scheme are not excluded from the Transfer of Undertakings Regulations (TUPE) merely because they are paid from a pension scheme. Only old…
R v Zezev
Denial-of-service attacks against electronic communications systems constitute criminal offences under the Computer Misuse Act 1990 and can be prosecuted even where the attack originates from abroad.
Lister v Hesley Hall Ltd
An employer is vicariously liable for the torts of an employee if there is a sufficiently close connection between the nature of the employment and the wrongful act. The 'close connection' test replaced the older…
Re A (Children) (Conjoined Twins: Surgical Separation)
The separation of conjoined twins, which would inevitably kill the weaker twin, was lawful. The operation was justified on the basis of necessity (the defence of others), as without it both twins would die. The doctors…
Attorney General v Blake
In exceptional circumstances, the court may award an account of profits for breach of contract — ordering the contract-breaker to pay over the profits made from the breach — even though the innocent party has suffered…
Reynolds v Times Newspapers Ltd
A new form of qualified privilege (later called 'Reynolds privilege') was available to the media where responsible journalism on a matter of public interest was practised. The court set out a non-exhaustive list of…
Z v United Kingdom
The failure of a local authority to protect children from severe neglect and abuse constituted a violation of Article 3 (prohibition of inhuman or degrading treatment). The state has a positive obligation to protect…
R v Lambert
Statutory reverse burdens of proof in criminal cases should be read down under s.3 HRA 1998 to impose only an evidential burden (duty to raise the issue) rather than a legal burden (duty to prove on the balance of…
R v Martin (Anthony)
Self-defence must be judged by the circumstances as the defendant honestly believed them to be. Psychiatric conditions affecting perception may be relevant to diminished responsibility.
Foskett v McKeown
Tracing is a process of identifying trust property as it moves through different forms. Beneficiaries whose money has been used to pay premiums on a life insurance policy are entitled to a proportionate share of the…
R v Offen
The automatic life sentence provisions under s 2 Crime (Sentences) Act 1997 should be read compatibly with Article 5 ECHR. A life sentence is not required where the offender does not pose a significant risk to the…
Modahl v British Athletic Federation Ltd
A sports governing body may be liable in negligence or breach of contract if its disciplinary procedures are fundamentally flawed, but demonstrating such a breach and causation of loss is difficult.
Watson v British Boxing Board of Control
A sports governing body that assumes responsibility for the medical safety of participants owes them a duty of care. If the body's rules require medical provision, it must ensure that provision is adequate.
R v Hinks
Appropriation for the purposes of theft can occur even where the owner consents to the transfer and the recipient obtains indefeasible title. The concept of appropriation is neutral — it is dishonesty that makes the…
R (Daly) v Secretary of State for the Home Department
A blanket policy requiring prisoners to be absent from their cells during searches of legally privileged correspondence is unlawful. Proportionality requires a more nuanced approach than Wednesbury unreasonableness.
Al-Adsani v United Kingdom
The grant of state immunity in civil proceedings concerning allegations of torture committed abroad does not violate Article 6 of the Convention: such immunity reflects generally recognised rules of international law…
Horvath v Secretary of State for the Home Department
The test for sufficiency of protection in asylum cases is whether the state provides a reasonable level of protection — not a guarantee of safety. A functioning system of criminal law and a willingness to enforce it is…
R v Betts and Hall
Where a suspect stays silent in police interview on legal advice, an adverse inference under section 34 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 may be drawn only if the jury is sure that the true reason for…
Manifest Shipping Co Ltd v Uni-Polaris Insurance Co Ltd (The Star Sea)
Under section 39(5) of the Marine Insurance Act 1906 an insurer escapes liability for loss attributable to unseaworthiness only where the assured was privy to sending the ship to sea in that state: privity requires…
White v White
In determining financial provision on divorce, there should be no discrimination between a breadwinner and a homemaker. The court should check any tentative award against the 'yardstick of equality' to ensure there is…
Bruton v London & Quadrant Housing Trust
A tenancy can be granted by a person who does not themselves hold an estate in the land. The grant of exclusive possession for a term at a rent creates a tenancy as between the parties, even if the grantor is only a…
Jolley v Sutton London Borough Council
For the purposes of both negligence and the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957, foreseeability of harm is assessed at the level of the type or kind of harm, not the precise mechanism by which it occurs. Where it is…
Re Barings plc (No 5)
A director who fails to acquire and maintain a sufficient knowledge and understanding of the company's business to enable proper discharge of duties may be found unfit to be a director. Directors have a duty to inform…
Designers Guild Ltd v Russell Williams (Textiles) Ltd
Copyright infringement requires proof that the defendant copied a substantial part of the claimant's work. Substantiality is assessed qualitatively, not merely quantitatively. The question is whether the copied features…
Lancashire County Council v B
Under the 'attributable' condition in section 31(2)(b)(i) of the Children Act 1989 the phrase 'care given to the child' refers primarily to the care given by a parent or parents or other primary carers; but in a…
R v Woollin
Where a defendant did not directly intend a result but the result was a virtually certain consequence of the defendant's actions, and the defendant appreciated that this was so, the jury is entitled to find (but is not…
White v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police
Police officers who attended the Hillsborough disaster as employees were not entitled to recover for psychiatric injury as rescuers unless they were in physical danger themselves. There is no special duty owed to…
Banque Financière de la Cité v Parc (Battersea) Ltd
A lender who discharges a secured debt of the borrower may be subrogated to the rights of the original secured creditor, even where there is no contractual or consensual basis for subrogation. Subrogation is a…
Kleinwort Benson Ltd v Lincoln City Council
Money paid under a mistake of law is recoverable in restitution on the same basis as money paid under a mistake of fact; a later judicial decision that changes the settled understanding of the law can found a claim that…
Harmon CFEM Facades (UK) Ltd v Corporate Officer of the House of Commons
A contracting authority that breaches the EU procurement rules by treating a tenderer unequally is liable in damages for the tenderer's wasted costs and loss of profit.
R v Bournewood Community and Mental Health NHS Trust, ex parte L
An informal (compliant but incapacitated) patient could be detained under the common law doctrine of necessity without recourse to the Mental Health Act 1983, creating a gap in safeguards later addressed by the…
Osman v DPP
A lawful stop and search under s.1 PACE 1984 requires the officer to have reasonable grounds for suspicion based on objective factors relating to the individual, not merely the area or time of day. A search conducted…
R v Aspinall
Evidence obtained from a mentally disordered or mentally vulnerable suspect interviewed without an appropriate adult present, as required by PACE Code C, is likely to be excluded under s.76 or s.78 PACE 1984 as…
Empress Car Company (Abertillery) Ltd v National Rivers Authority
The offence of causing polluting matter to enter controlled waters under the Water Resources Act 1991 is one of strict liability. A person 'causes' pollution if they maintain something which, combined with a foreseeable…
Buchanan v Milton
There is no property in a dead body. The person with the highest claim to administer the estate has the right and duty to arrange for the disposal of the body.
Osman v United Kingdom
The state has a positive obligation under Article 2 (right to life) to take preventive operational measures to protect an individual whose life is at risk from the criminal acts of another, where the authorities knew or…
Mullin v Richards
The standard of care expected of a child defendant is that of a reasonably careful child of the same age, not that of a reasonable adult. The question is whether an ordinarily prudent and reasonable child of that age…
Investors Compensation Scheme Ltd v West Bromwich Building Society
Contractual interpretation is an objective exercise ascertaining the meaning a reasonable person with all the background knowledge available to the parties would give to the language used. The background includes…
Malik v Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA
There is an implied term of mutual trust and confidence in every employment contract. The employer must not, without reasonable and proper cause, conduct itself in a manner calculated or likely to destroy or seriously…
Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority
The Bolam test requires the body of medical opinion relied upon to have a logical basis. The court is not bound to accept expert evidence that is not capable of withstanding logical analysis, even if held by a…
R v Brewster
When suspending a sentence of imprisonment, the court must consider whether the case meets the custody threshold and then whether there are factors that justify suspension. A suspended sentence is still a sentence of…
Re BCCI (No 8)
A bank may take a valid proprietary charge over its own customer's deposit with the bank as security for that customer's or a third party's liabilities. This is conceptually possible and is not inconsistent with the…
Hunter v Canary Wharf Ltd
Private nuisance is a tort that protects interests in land. Only a person with a proprietary interest in the affected land — such as an owner, tenant, or holder of an exclusive licence — has standing to sue in private…
R (Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants) v Secretary of State for the Home Department
Regulations that deny welfare benefits to asylum seekers who fail to claim asylum on arrival render the right to claim asylum under the Refugee Convention nugatory and are therefore ultra vires.
Ruxley Electronics and Construction Ltd v Forsyth
Where a contract for building works specifies a particular standard or dimension, but the works are carried out defectively, the appropriate measure of damages depends on what would be reasonable in all the…
Page v Smith
A primary victim (someone within the range of foreseeable physical injury) can recover for psychiatric illness even if physical injury was foreseeable but psychiatric injury was not. There is no need to show that…
R v Preddy
A mortgage advance obtained by deception did not constitute 'obtaining property belonging to another' under s.15 Theft Act 1968 because the bank transfer created a new chose in action rather than transferring existing…
Re H (Minors) (Sexual Abuse: Standard of Proof)
In care proceedings, suspicion alone, however strong, cannot satisfy the threshold in section 31(2) of the Children Act 1989; the facts relied upon to establish a real possibility of future significant harm must…
R v Adomako
Gross negligence manslaughter is committed where: (1) the defendant owed the deceased a duty of care under the ordinary common-law principles of negligence; (2) the defendant breached that duty; (3) the breach caused…
Royal Brunei Airlines v Tan
A defendant who dishonestly assists a trustee to commit a breach of trust is personally liable to the beneficiaries as an accessory, even if the trustee was not dishonest. The critical requirement for accessory…
Henderson v Merrett Syndicates Ltd
A duty of care in tort may exist concurrently with contractual obligations. Where a person assumes responsibility for providing professional services and another relies on that assumption of responsibility, a tortious…
White v Jones
A solicitor retained by a testator to prepare a will owes a duty of care to the intended beneficiaries. If the solicitor's negligence results in the beneficiaries receiving less than intended, they may recover damages…
R v Kingston
Involuntary intoxication is not a defence to a criminal charge if the defendant still formed the necessary mens rea. A drugged intent is still an intent. The fact that the defendant would not have committed the offence…
R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Fire Brigades Union
A minister cannot use prerogative powers to frustrate the will of Parliament by introducing a scheme that effectively prevents a statutory scheme from being brought into force.
R v Somerset County Council, ex parte Fewings
Public bodies can only do what they are lawfully authorised to do. Unlike private individuals, they have no general freedom of action — they must point to a specific power authorising their actions.
R v Makanjuola
Following the abolition of mandatory corroboration warnings by the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994, it remains open to a judge to give a warning about the reliability of a witness where appropriate, but such…
Spring v Guardian Assurance plc
An employer owes a duty of care to an employee or former employee when providing a reference. A negligently prepared reference causing economic loss to the subject is actionable in negligence.
Re Selectmove Ltd
A promise to pay an existing debt by instalments is not supported by consideration, following the rule in Foakes v Beer. The practical benefit approach from Williams v Roffey Bros does not extend to promises to pay…
Union Royale Belge des Sociétés de Football Association ASBL v Bosman
Rules requiring transfer fees for out-of-contract players, and rules limiting the number of EU nationals a club may field, constitute restrictions on the free movement of workers contrary to what is now Article 45 TFEU.
R v Coroner for North Humberside, ex parte Jamieson
An inquest is an inquisitorial fact-finding process and not a means of determining criminal or civil liability. The verdict must not appear to determine any such liability.
Tesco Stores Ltd v Secretary of State for the Environment
Planning obligations (s.106 agreements) are material considerations in determining planning applications. However, the weight to be given to such obligations is a matter for the decision-maker, and they must be fairly…
Cambridge Water Co v Eastern Counties Leather plc
Foreseeability of damage of the relevant type is a prerequisite for liability under the rule in Rylands v Fletcher and in nuisance. The rule in Rylands v Fletcher is a sub-species of nuisance and should be developed in…
R v Brown
Consent is not a defence to the infliction of actual bodily harm or more serious injury for the purpose of sadomasochistic activities. The House of Lords held (by a 3–2 majority) that public policy required that consent…
City of London Corporation v Fell
An original tenant's liability in contract on the covenants of a lease is co-extensive with the contractual term the parties agreed. Where a lease is assigned and the assignee then holds over under the statutory…
Pan Atlantic Insurance Co Ltd v Pine Top Insurance Co Ltd
A circumstance is "material" under ss 18(2) and 20(2) of the Marine Insurance Act 1906 if it would have an effect on the mind or thought processes of a prudent insurer in weighing up the risk; it need not have had a…
Airedale NHS Trust v Bland
It is lawful to withdraw life-sustaining treatment (including artificial nutrition and hydration) from a patient in a persistent vegetative state where it is in the patient's best interests, provided the court's prior…
Pepper (Inspector of Taxes) v Hart
The strict exclusionary rule against reference to Parliamentary materials in statutory interpretation (established in Davis v Johnson [1979] AC 264 and earlier authority) is relaxed. Where primary legislation is (a)…
Re Atlantic Computer Systems plc
The court established guidelines for the exercise of discretion to grant leave to proceed against a company in administration. The administrator's proposals should normally be given a chance to succeed, but the rights…
R v Gotts
Duress is not available as a defence to a charge of attempted murder. The reasoning in R v Howe [1987] AC 417 — that the taking of an innocent life cannot be justified by duress because society's interest in the…
Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police
A secondary victim claiming for psychiatric injury caused by witnessing an accident must satisfy proximity requirements: (1) a close tie of love and affection with the primary victim; (2) proximity in time and space to…
Owens Bank Ltd v Bracco
A foreign judgment obtained by fraud cannot be enforced in England. The fraud exception to recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments is not limited to fraud discovered after the original proceedings.
City Index Ltd v Leslie
Spread betting contracts are not void as wagering contracts under the Gaming Act 1845 because they are contracts for differences, not wagers on the outcome of events.
Williams v Roffey Bros & Nicholls (Contractors) Ltd
Where a party to an existing contract promises additional payment in return for the other party's promise to perform existing contractual obligations, and the promisor thereby obtains a practical benefit or avoids a…
Murphy v Brentwood District Council
A local authority owes no duty of care in negligence to a purchaser of a house for the cost of repairing defects in the building arising from inadequate foundations approved by the authority under its building control…
R v Cheshire
The defendant's act need not be the sole or even the main cause of death; it is sufficient that it contributed significantly to the result. Only if the original wound has healed and the medical treatment is so…
R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex parte Factortame Ltd (No 2)
By the European Communities Act 1972, Parliament supremely and deliberately chose to give precedence to directly enforceable Community law over inconsistent domestic legislation. English courts must therefore, where…
Lloyds Bank plc v Rosset
A beneficial interest in property held in another's sole name can be established through a constructive trust in two ways only. First, where there is evidence of an express common intention to share beneficial…
R v Registrar of Companies, ex parte Attorney General
A company registered for an unlawful purpose (in this case, prostitution) may be struck off the register. The Registrar has a duty to refuse or cancel registration where the company's objects are wholly unlawful.
Lipkin Gorman v Karpnale Ltd
English law recognises a cause of action in unjust enrichment (restitution) at common law. The defence of change of position is available where the defendant has changed their position in good faith in reliance on the…
Imperial Group Pension Trust Ltd v Imperial Tobacco Ltd
An employer exercising powers under a pension scheme is subject to an implied duty of good faith — it must not exercise its powers for an improper purpose or perversely.
Caparo Industries plc v Dickman
A duty of care in the tort of negligence arises only where three conditions are simultaneously satisfied: (1) the harm caused was a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the defendant's conduct; (2) there was a…
Adams v Cape Industries plc
The corporate veil will only be lifted in limited circumstances: where the company is a mere façade concealing the true facts, where a company is an agent of its parent, or where statute authorises it. The fact that a…
Smith v Eric S Bush
A valuer instructed by a building society to value a modest residential property owes a duty of care to the purchaser, even though the valuer's contract is with the building society, because the valuer knows that the…
Barber v Guardian Royal Exchange Assurance Group
Occupational pension benefits constitute 'pay' within the meaning of Article 119 of the Treaty of Rome (now Article 157 TFEU). Unequal pensionable ages for men and women in occupational pension schemes therefore breach…
Pacific Associates Inc v Baxter
An engineer engaged by the employer to supervise construction work and certify interim payments owes no duty of care in tort to the contractor for economic loss caused by negligent certification or rejection of claims…
Interfoto Picture Library Ltd v Stiletto Visual Programmes Ltd
If a condition in a contract is particularly onerous or unusual, the party seeking to enforce it must show that it was fairly and reasonably brought to the other party's attention. Failure to give adequate notice means…
Polkey v AE Dayton Services Ltd
An employer dismissing an employee for redundancy or misconduct cannot escape a finding of unfair dismissal by arguing that following a fair procedure would have made no difference to the outcome. Whether the procedure…
Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority
Where there are multiple possible causes of the claimant's injury, the claimant must prove on the balance of probabilities that the defendant's negligence was a cause. It is not sufficient to show that the defendant's…
R v Gold; R v Schifreen
Unauthorised access to a computer system by using stolen credentials did not constitute an offence under the Forgery and Counterfeiting Act 1981 because a password is not a 'false instrument'. This case exposed a gap in…
West Mercia Safetywear Ltd v Dodd
When a company is insolvent or of doubtful solvency, directors owe a duty to have regard to the interests of creditors. A director who causes the company to act to the detriment of creditors may be required to make good…
R v Samuel
The right of access to legal advice under s.58 PACE 1984 is a fundamental right. Delay can only be authorised under s.58(8) where the officer has reasonable grounds to believe access to a solicitor will lead to specific…
Spiliada Maritime Corp v Cansulex Ltd
A stay of English proceedings on grounds of forum non conveniens will be granted where the defendant shows that there is another available forum which is clearly more appropriate for the trial of the action. The court…
R v Howe
Duress is not available as a defence to murder, whether as a principal or as an aider and abettor. A person who takes an innocent life cannot invoke threats to their own life as a defence.
Re St Stephen Walbrook
A faculty could be granted to install a Henry Moore altar (a large circular stone sculpture) in a Wren church, notwithstanding that it departed from traditional altar design, provided the change served the needs of…
Smith v Littlewoods Organisation Ltd
As a general rule, the common law does not impose a duty of care to prevent a third party from causing damage to another. Omissions that permit a third party to harm do not usually ground liability. However, exceptions…
R v Andrews
A statement made by a person so shortly after an event and in circumstances so closely associated with it that the mind was still dominated by the event is admissible as a res gestae statement, provided there was no…
Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech Area Health Authority
A child under 16 can consent to medical treatment (including contraceptive advice and treatment) without parental knowledge or consent, provided the child has sufficient understanding and intelligence to fully…
R v Nedrick
For the purposes of murder, where the defendant's purpose was not to kill or cause grievous bodily harm, the jury may find the requisite specific intent only if they are satisfied that: (a) death or serious bodily harm…
Street v Mountford
The grant of exclusive possession of residential premises for a term at a rent creates a tenancy regardless of how the parties label their agreement. The substance of the arrangement, not its form, determines whether a…
Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service
The exercise of powers derived from the royal prerogative is, in principle, subject to judicial review in the same way as powers derived from statute, provided the subject matter is justiciable. The grounds for judicial…
Antaios Compania Naviera SA v Salen Rederierna AB (The Antaios)
Where, in the process of construing a commercial contract, there are two competing interpretations and one produces a commercially absurd result while the other produces a result consistent with business common sense…
R v Lloyd
A temporary borrowing of property does not amount to an intention permanently to deprive the owner within s.6 of the Theft Act 1968 unless the intention is to return the thing only after all its 'goodness, virtue, or…
Rhesa Shipping Co SA v Edmunds (The Popi M)
In a case where the cause of a vessel's loss is unknown, the court is not required to choose between two improbable explanations. The burden of proof remains on the claimant, and if neither explanation is established on…
Cowan v Scargill
Pension fund trustees must exercise their investment powers in the best financial interests of the beneficiaries. They must not allow their personal views (including political or moral beliefs) to influence investment…
Burns v Burns
An unmarried cohabitant who makes no financial contribution to the purchase price or mortgage of a property has no beneficial interest under a resulting or constructive trust, even after 17 years of cohabitation and…
Amin Rasheed Shipping Corp v Kuwait Insurance Co
The proper law of a contract is the system of law with which the transaction has its closest and most real connection, determined objectively where the parties have not made an express choice.
Mandla v Dowell Lee
Sikhs constitute an ethnic group within the meaning of the Race Relations Act 1976. To qualify as an ethnic group, a community must regard itself, and be regarded by others, as a distinct community by virtue of certain…
R v Pagett
The reasonable act of a third party acting in self-defence or in the execution of duty does not break the chain of causation. The defendant who creates the dangerous situation remains the legal cause of the victim's…
Iceland Frozen Foods Ltd v Jones
The function of the tribunal in unfair dismissal cases is to determine whether the dismissal fell within the range of reasonable responses open to a reasonable employer, not to substitute its own view of the right…
Aktieselskabet de Danske Sukkerfabrikker v Bajamar Compania Naviera SA (The Torenia)
A time charterer is liable for the consequences of nominating an unsafe port, even if the unsafety could not have been anticipated at the time of nomination, unless the master could have avoided the danger by reasonable…
Raymond v Honey
A convicted prisoner, in spite of his imprisonment, retains all civil rights which are not taken away expressly or by necessary implication, including the fundamental right of unimpeded access to the courts; prison…
R v Ghosh
Under the Theft Act 1968, dishonesty is a component of the offence of theft and related offences. The Ghosh test for dishonesty was: (1) was what the defendant did dishonest according to the ordinary standards of…
Jobling v Associated Dairies Ltd
Where a non-tortious supervening event (such as a naturally occurring illness) overtakes the original injury and would have produced the same disability regardless, the first tortfeasor's liability is limited to the…
R v Graham
The defence of duress requires: (1) genuine fear of death or serious injury; (2) a sober person of reasonable firmness sharing the defendant's characteristics would have responded the same way.
R v Caldwell
Recklessness for criminal damage included objective situations where the defendant either recognised a risk and unreasonably took it, or failed to give any thought to an obvious risk ('Caldwell recklessness').
W T Ramsay Ltd v IRC
It is the task of the court to ascertain the legal nature of a transaction to which a tax consequence is sought to be attached, and where that emerges from a pre-ordained series or combination of transactions intended…
Williams & Glyn's Bank v Boland
A person in actual occupation of registered land has an overriding interest that binds a purchaser, even if the purchaser did not know of the occupation. A spouse who has contributed to the purchase price and is in…
Bunge Corporation v Tradax Export SA
In mercantile contracts, time stipulations are generally conditions, breach of which entitles the innocent party to terminate regardless of the seriousness of the consequences. Certainty is of paramount importance in…
Attorney General v BBC
The Contempt of Court Act 1981 strict liability rule applies only to publications creating a substantial risk of serious prejudice to active proceedings. A mere incidental risk is insufficient.
Photo Production Ltd v Securicor Transport Ltd
An exclusion clause in a commercial contract between parties of equal bargaining strength can be effective to exclude liability even for a fundamental breach or a deliberate wrongful act by the defendant's employee…
Belmont Finance Corporation v Williams Furniture Ltd (No 2)
A person who knowingly receives trust property transferred in breach of trust is liable as a constructive trustee, even if they are a company. Knowledge in this context includes actual knowledge, wilful blindness, and…
Malone v Metropolitan Police Commissioner
Telephone tapping by the police, though not specifically authorised by statute, was not illegal because there was no right to privacy recognised at common law. However, the case highlighted the inadequacy of English law…
Winterwerp v Netherlands
Detention on the ground of unsoundness of mind is only lawful under Article 5(1)(e) ECHR if the individual is reliably shown by objective medical expertise to be of unsound mind, the disorder is of a kind or degree…
Western Excavating (ECC) Ltd v Sharp
Constructive dismissal requires a fundamental breach of contract by the employer. The test is contractual, not based on the employer's unreasonable conduct. The employee must show the employer breached a fundamental…
British Home Stores Ltd v Burchell
In cases of dismissal for misconduct, the employer must show: (1) a genuine belief in the employee's guilt, (2) reasonable grounds for that belief, and (3) a reasonable investigation. The tribunal must not substitute…
Anns v Merton London Borough Council
Lord Wilberforce's two-stage test for the existence of a duty of care: first, ask whether between the defendant and the claimant there is sufficient proximity such that carelessness might cause damage to the claimant…
Batty v Metropolitan Property Realisations Ltd
A developer owes a duty of care to purchasers in respect of the fitness of the site for building, even where the actual construction work is carried out by independent contractors.
DPP v Majewski
Voluntary intoxication (by alcohol or drugs) is no defence to a charge of a 'basic intent' offence (one that can be committed recklessly). However, voluntary intoxication may be a defence to a 'specific intent' offence…
Woodward v Hutchins
A person who has courted publicity and deliberately projected an enhanced public image to the world cannot invoke the equitable duty of confidence to suppress truthful information that corrects that false image. The…
Paul v Constance
An express declaration of trust over personalty (such as a bank account) requires no particular formalities and need not use technical language. It is sufficient that, looking at all the circumstances and the words…
R v Turnbull
Where the prosecution case depends wholly or substantially on identification evidence, the judge must warn the jury of the special need for caution and direct them to examine the circumstances of the identification…
Barton v Armstrong
Where a party enters into a contract partly because of physical duress (threats of violence or death) and partly for independent commercial reasons, the contract is voidable if the duress was a cause — not necessarily…
R v Mohan
Direct intent for a criminal attempt requires a decision by the defendant to bring about, insofar as it lies within their power, the proscribed consequence — namely, the commission of the full offence. It is not…
DHN Food Distributors Ltd v Tower Hamlets London Borough Council
The corporate veil may be lifted to treat a group of companies as a single economic entity where the subsidiaries are wholly owned and controlled by the parent, and justice requires it.
DPP v Newbury and Jones
A defendant is guilty of unlawful act (constructive) manslaughter if it is proved that he intentionally did an act which was unlawful and dangerous and that act inadvertently caused death; it is unnecessary to prove…
Eves v Eves
Where a common intention to share beneficial ownership is established (even if the expressed reason for not putting the property in joint names is false), and the claimant acts to their detriment in reliance on that…
R v Blaue
The thin skull rule applies in criminal law. A defendant must take their victim as they find them, including religious beliefs. A victim's refusal of treatment on religious grounds does not break the chain of causation.
Re Kayford Ltd
Where a company in financial difficulty segregates customer deposits into a separate trust account, those funds are held on trust for the customers and do not form part of the company's assets available to general…
British Eagle International Airlines Ltd v Compagnie Nationale Air France
Contractual arrangements that have the effect of contracting out of the statutory scheme for pari passu distribution in insolvency are contrary to public policy and void.
Wilson v Racher
A single act of insubordination does not necessarily justify summary dismissal. The context, provocation, and all circumstances must be considered. The old master-servant approach to employment is outdated.
Smedleys Ltd v Breed
Food safety offences are strict liability. The presence of extraneous matter (a caterpillar in a tin of peas) constitutes an offence regardless of the manufacturer's care, subject to the statutory defences.
Dingle v Turner
A trust for the relief of poverty among employees of a particular company can be charitable, because trusts for the relief of poverty have always been treated more favourably regarding public benefit than trusts for…
Tesco Supermarkets Ltd v Nattrass
A company can rely on the due diligence defence where the offence was committed by a store manager (another person) and the company had set up a proper system of training and supervision. The manager is not the alter…
Nettleship v Weston
The standard of care expected of a learner driver is the same as that of a reasonably competent experienced driver. The standard of care in negligence is objective — it does not take account of the particular…
R v Roberts
Where a victim takes evasive action to escape the defendant's unlawful conduct, the defendant is liable for the resulting injuries provided the victim's reaction was within the range of reasonably foreseeable responses.
McPhail v Doulton (Re Baden's Deed Trusts No 1)
The test for certainty of objects in a discretionary trust is the 'is or is not' test: the trust is valid if it can be said with certainty that any given individual is or is not a member of the class.
Boys v Chaplin
In tort claims with a foreign element, the English court may apply the law of the place where the tort occurred (lex loci delicti), but flexibility exists to apply English law where justice requires.
R v Marriott
Possession of a controlled drug requires proof that the defendant had a substance in their possession and knew it was a controlled drug, or was wilfully blind to that fact.
R v Marriott
A person is not in unlawful possession of a drug which, unknown to him, is adhering to an article in his custody: proof of mere possession of the article, without more, is not enough. The prosecution must establish that…
R v Gosney
Driving in a manner dangerous to the public was not an absolute offence: fault on the part of the driver was a necessary ingredient. A conviction required not only a situation which, viewed objectively, was dangerous…
Baker v Willoughby
Where the claimant suffers a subsequent injury from a different tortfeasor or event, the first tortfeasor remains liable for the original loss. The subsequent event does not reduce the first tortfeasor's liability.
R v Caird
Those who take part in mob violence must expect severe sentences. The courts must impose deterrent sentences where group disorder threatens public order.
Fagan v Metropolitan Police Commissioner
Where an act constituting the actus reus is a continuing act, the mens rea need not be present at the inception of the act but may be superimposed upon it while it is still continuing. The actus reus and mens rea must…
Barnett v Chelsea & Kensington Hospital Management Committee
Even where a defendant owes a duty of care and is in breach of that duty, the claimant must still prove factual causation — that 'but for' the breach, the damage would not have occurred. If the claimant would have…
Anisminic Ltd v Foreign Compensation Commission
Any error of law by a public body or tribunal renders its decision a nullity. There is no meaningful distinction between 'jurisdictional' and 'non-jurisdictional' errors of law for the purpose of judicial review. An…
Re Resch's Will Trusts
A trust for the establishment of a private hospital charging fees is charitable if it relieves the burden on public healthcare services and does not exclude the poor from any benefit it might provide to the community.
Beswick v Beswick
A third party cannot enforce a contract to which they are not a party (privity of contract). However, a party to the contract can obtain specific performance for the benefit of a third party where damages would be…
Padfield v Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food
A statutory discretion is never unfettered. It must be exercised to promote the policy and objects of the Act conferring it. A minister who refuses to exercise a discretion for reasons that frustrate the Act's purpose…
Partridge v Crittenden
An advertisement in a periodical stating a price for goods is an invitation to treat, not an offer for sale, unless the language clearly indicates otherwise.
Boardman v Phipps
A fiduciary who obtains a profit by virtue of their fiduciary position must account for that profit to the beneficiaries, even if they acted in good faith and even if the trust could not have obtained the profit itself.
Overseas Tankship (UK) Ltd v The Miller Steamship Co (The Wagon Mound No 2)
Damage is reasonably foreseeable (and therefore not too remote) if there is a real risk of its occurrence, even if the probability is small. A reasonable person would not ignore a risk which was real and not far-fetched…
Chadwick v British Railways Board
A rescuer who suffers psychiatric injury from the horrifying scenes encountered during rescue operations may recover damages from the party whose negligence caused the original accident, provided the rescuer was exposed…
R v Lamb
For unlawful act manslaughter, the unlawful act must be intentional. Pointing a revolver as a joke where both parties believed it would not fire does not constitute assault.
R v Church
Constructive (unlawful act) manslaughter requires proof of: (a) an unlawful act; (b) which is dangerous in the objective sense that all sober and reasonable people would inevitably recognise it as subjecting the victim…
Wheat v E Lacon & Co Ltd
There may be more than one occupier of premises for the purposes of the Occupiers' Liability Act 1957. An occupier is a person who has a sufficient degree of control over the premises to be under a duty of care to…
Rice v Connolly
A citizen has no general legal duty to assist the police or answer their questions. Refusing to answer questions or to accompany police voluntarily does not constitute obstruction of a police officer in the execution of…
Letang v Cooper
Where personal injury is caused unintentionally, the appropriate cause of action is negligence, not trespass to the person. Trespass to the person should be confined to intentional acts.
Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd
A duty of care can arise in respect of negligent misstatements causing pure economic loss where there is a 'special relationship' between the parties — that is, the defendant assumed responsibility for the accuracy of…
Ridge v Baldwin
The rules of natural justice — particularly the right to be heard (audi alteram partem) — apply to every body of persons having authority to make decisions involving civil consequences for an individual. The doctrine is…
Eastham v Newcastle United FC
The football retain-and-transfer system constituted an unreasonable restraint of trade. A player could not be indefinitely retained by a club after his contract expired, preventing him from joining another club.
Hong Kong Fir Shipping Co Ltd v Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd
Not all contractual terms can be classified as conditions or warranties. Some terms are 'innominate' (intermediate) — whether breach entitles the innocent party to terminate depends on the nature and consequences of the…
Smith v Leech Brain & Co Ltd
The 'thin skull' rule (egg-shell skull rule) survived The Wagon Mound (No 1). A tortfeasor must take the victim as they find them. It is sufficient that the type of damage (physical injury) was foreseeable; the…
DPP v Smith
An objective test for intention in murder was established: a person is presumed to intend the natural and probable consequences of their actions. This decision was later reversed by statute (s.8 Criminal Justice Act…
Lee v Lee's Air Farming Ltd
A person can be both the controlling shareholder and managing director of a company and simultaneously be employed by that company as a worker. The company is a separate legal entity from its shareholders and directors…
Fisher v Bell
The display of goods in a shop window with a price tag is an invitation to treat, not an offer. A shopkeeper who displays a flick knife in his window is not 'offering it for sale' within the meaning of the Restriction…
Overseas Tankship (UK) Ltd v Morts Dock & Engineering Co Ltd (The Wagon Mound No 1)
The test for remoteness of damage in negligence is reasonable foreseeability: a defendant is liable only for damage of a kind that a reasonable person in their position would have foreseen as a real risk at the time of…
Chappell & Co Ltd v Nestlé Co Ltd
Consideration need not be adequate but must be sufficient. Even trivial items (such as chocolate bar wrappers) can constitute good consideration if they are part of the bargain, even if they have no intrinsic economic…
R v Smith (Thomas Joseph)
For the purposes of criminal responsibility for homicide, the defendant's original act need not be the sole or even the main cause of death. Provided the original wound is still an operating and substantial cause of…
Fowler v Lanning
In a modern action for trespass to the person, the burden of proving that the defendant acted intentionally or negligently rests on the claimant. The claimant must plead whether the act was intentional or negligent.
R v Cunningham
The word 'maliciously' in a criminal statute requires proof that the defendant either intended the particular kind of harm that in fact occurred, or was reckless as to whether such harm should occur — i.e., the…
Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee
A doctor is not negligent if they act in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical opinion, even if other doctors would have acted differently. This is the 'Bolam test' for…
J Spurling Ltd v Bradshaw
A particularly onerous or unusual clause must be fairly and reasonably brought to the other party's attention. The more unusual or onerous the clause, the greater the degree of notice required (the 'red hand' rule).
Bonnington Castings Ltd v Wardlaw
Where a disease is caused by cumulative exposure, it is sufficient for the claimant to show that the defendant's breach made a material contribution to the injury. The claimant need not show that the breach was the sole…
R v Jordan
In exceptional circumstances, grossly negligent medical treatment can break the chain of causation where the original wound has substantially healed and the treatment is 'palpably wrong'.
Re Ellenborough Park
An easement must possess four characteristics: (1) there must be a dominant and a servient tenement; (2) the easement must accommodate the dominant tenement — benefiting the land itself, not merely conferring a personal…
Entores Ltd v Miles Far East Corporation
Where communication is instantaneous (such as telephone, telex, or other direct communication), a contract is formed at the place and time when the acceptance is received by the offeror, not where and when it is sent…
Watt v Hertfordshire County Council
The social utility of the defendant's activity is a relevant factor in assessing breach of duty. Where the activity has high social value (such as emergency rescue), a greater degree of risk may be acceptable.
Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots Cash Chemists
The display of goods on a self-service shop shelf is an invitation to treat, not an offer. The customer makes the offer when presenting goods at the cash desk, and the shopkeeper accepts (or may decline) at that point…
Latimer v AEC Ltd
The standard of care required of an employer does not demand that all risk of injury be eliminated regardless of cost or disruption. The court must weigh the magnitude of the risk created against the burden of the…
Re Rose
Where a donor has done everything in their power to transfer legal title, equity will treat the gift as complete even before the legal formalities are finalised by a third party.
R v Tronoh Mines Ltd
For an advertisement to be an election expense, it must be specifically directed to affecting the result in a particular constituency rather than a general political advertisement.
Bolton v Stone
A defendant is not negligent merely because injury is a foreseeable possibility. The risk must be sufficiently probable that a reasonable person would take precautions against it. A very small risk may be disregarded if…
Paris v Stepney Borough Council
In assessing whether a defendant has taken reasonable care in breach of duty, the court must weigh the magnitude of the risk against the precautions available. The magnitude of the risk comprises both the probability…
Combe v Combe
Promissory estoppel can only be used as a defence (a shield), not as a cause of action (a sword). It does not create new rights but prevents a party from going back on a promise in certain circumstances.
Oppenheim v Tobacco Securities Trust Co Ltd
A trust for the advancement of education must benefit a sufficient section of the public to be charitable. A trust limited to the children of employees of a particular company is not charitable because the beneficiaries…
Olley v Marlborough Court Hotel Ltd
Terms displayed after the contract is formed are not incorporated into it. The contract is formed at the point of agreement (e.g., at the reception desk), not when the parties later encounter the terms.
Victoria Laundry (Windsor) Ltd v Newman Industries Ltd
Damages for breach of contract are limited to losses within the reasonable contemplation of the parties at the time of contract. Losses arising naturally from the breach (first limb of Hadley v Baxendale) are…
Edwards v National Coal Board
"Reasonably practicable" is a narrower term than "physically possible": the duty-holder must make a computation in which the quantum of risk is placed on one scale and the sacrifice involved in the measures necessary…
Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation
A decision of a public authority can be challenged on the ground that it is so unreasonable that no reasonable authority could ever have come to it (Wednesbury unreasonableness). The court will intervene if the…
Re Diplock
Where executors distribute estate funds to persons not entitled under the will, the rightful beneficiaries have both a personal claim against the wrongly paid recipients and a proprietary claim to trace the money in…
National Anti-Vivisection Society v IRC
A trust whose main purpose is to change the law cannot be charitable because the court cannot determine whether the proposed change would be for the public benefit. Additionally, a purpose may not be charitable if its…
Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd
Where a party makes a promise intended to be binding, intended to be acted upon, and in fact acted upon, that party will not be permitted to revert to the original legal position as if the promise had not been made…
Scammell v Ouston
An agreement is void for uncertainty if its terms are so vague that they cannot be given a definite meaning. The court cannot make a contract for the parties where the essential terms are insufficiently certain.
Chapelton v Barry Urban District Council
An exclusion clause on a receipt or ticket may not be incorporated into the contract if the ticket is not reasonably regarded as a contractual document but merely as a receipt or voucher.
McCrone v Riding
The standard of driving required by the offence of driving without due care and attention is an objective standard, impersonal and universal, fixed in relation to the safety of other users of the highway. It is in no…
Woolmington v DPP
Throughout the web of the English criminal law one golden thread is always to be seen — that it is the duty of the prosecution to prove the prisoner's guilt. The burden of proof lies on the prosecution from start to…
Gilford Motor Co Ltd v Horne
The corporate veil will be pierced where a company is used as a device or stratagem to evade an existing legal obligation, such as a restrictive covenant.
Donoghue v Stevenson
A manufacturer of products owes a duty of care to the ultimate consumer where the products reach the consumer in the form in which they left the manufacturer, with no reasonable possibility of intermediate examination…
Macaura v Northern Assurance Co Ltd
A shareholder, even a sole shareholder, has no insurable interest in the property owned by the company because the company is a separate legal person distinct from its members. The shareholder owns shares, which…
Elder Dempster & Co Ltd v Paterson Zochonis & Co Ltd
Stevedores employed by a carrier may be entitled to rely on the exceptions and limitations in the bill of lading contract, even though they are not parties to it, where there is an implied bailment on terms.
Re Polemis & Furness, Withy & Co Ltd
Once some damage was foreseeable from the defendant's negligent act, the defendant was liable for all direct consequences, however unforeseeable. This is the 'directness' test of remoteness.
Balfour v Balfour
Agreements between spouses relating to their domestic arrangements are not contracts because the parties do not intend to create legal relations. There is a presumption against contractual intention in domestic and…
Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd v New Garage & Motor Co Ltd
A contractual clause requiring the payment of a stipulated sum on breach of contract is enforceable as liquidated damages if it represents a genuine pre-estimate of the loss which the innocent party will suffer from…
Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd v Selfridge & Co Ltd
The doctrine of privity of contract means that only a party to a contract — someone who gave consideration and was a party to the agreement — may sue to enforce it. A third party who was the intended beneficiary of a…
British Westinghouse Electric v Underground Electric Railways
The innocent party has a duty to mitigate their loss following a breach of contract. If the claimant takes reasonable steps in mitigation and those steps produce a benefit that exceeds the loss, the defendant is not…
R v White
The 'but for' test of factual causation: the defendant's act must be a factual cause of the prohibited result. If the victim would have died the same way regardless, causation is not established.
Herne Bay Steam Boat Co v Hutton
A contract is not frustrated merely because an event that formed one party's motive for entering the contract fails to occur. Frustration only applies where the supervening event destroys the foundation or common…
Krell v Henry
A contract may be frustrated where a supervening event destroys the entire foundation or purpose of the contract, rendering it radically different from what was contemplated. It is not necessary that performance be…
Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd
A properly incorporated company is a separate legal entity from its shareholders, even where one person effectively controls the company and is its principal shareholder. The company's debts are not the debts of its…
Rochefoucauld v Boustead
The Statute of Frauds cannot be used as an instrument of fraud. Where a person acquires land on an oral understanding to hold it on trust for another, equity will enforce the trust despite the lack of written evidence.
Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co
An advertisement can constitute a unilateral offer to the world at large, which is accepted by performing the stipulated conditions. Consideration is provided by the inconvenience of performing those conditions. The…
Harvey v Facey
A statement of the minimum price at which a party would sell is not an offer to sell — it is merely a supply of information. An offer requires a clear indication of willingness to be bound on stated terms.
Derry v Peek
Fraud (deceit) is proved when it is shown that a false representation was made knowingly, without belief in its truth, or recklessly (careless whether it be true or false). An honest belief in the truth of a statement…
The Moorcock
A term will be implied into a contract where it is necessary to give business efficacy to the contract — that is, where without the term the contract would lack commercial or practical coherence.
R v Latimer
The doctrine of transferred malice: where the defendant intends to harm one person but accidentally harms another, the mens rea is transferred to the actual victim.
R v Dudley and Stephens
Necessity is not a defence to murder. The deliberate killing of an innocent person, however extreme the circumstances and however genuine the belief that killing was necessary to preserve the lives of others…
Foakes v Beer
Payment of a lesser sum cannot be satisfaction for a greater debt. The rule in Pinnel's Case (1602) was affirmed: a creditor's promise to accept part payment in full settlement is not binding for want of consideration…
Walsh v Lonsdale
Where parties have entered into a specifically enforceable agreement for a lease, equity treats them as if the legal lease had already been executed. This is an application of the maxim that equity treats as done that…
Sturges v Bridgman
What amounts to a nuisance depends on the character of the locality. The standard is that of the reasonable user of land in that particular neighbourhood. A prescriptive right to commit a nuisance cannot be acquired…
Poussard v Spiers and Pond
A term going to the root of the contract is a condition. Breach of a condition entitles the innocent party to terminate the contract and claim damages.
Bettini v Gye
A contractual term that does not go to the root of the contract is a warranty rather than a condition. Breach of a warranty entitles the innocent party to damages only, and not to terminate the contract. Whether a term…
Currie v Misa
Valuable consideration in the sense of the law may consist either in some right, interest, profit, or benefit accruing to the one party, or some forbearance, detriment, loss, or responsibility, given, suffered, or…
R v Pembliton
Transferred malice operates only within the same type of offence. An intention to assault or strike a person cannot be transferred to the different offence of criminal damage to property; the mens rea for one kind of…
Pilcher v Rawlins
A bona fide purchaser for value of the legal estate without notice of a prior equitable interest takes free from that interest. This defence—equity's darling—is a complete answer to equitable claims.
Smith v Hughes
The question is not what was the intention of the parties but what would a reasonable person understand the parties' intentions to be from their words and conduct. The objective test of agreement prevails over…
Banks v Goodfellow
To make a valid will, the testator must: (1) understand the nature of the act and its effects; (2) understand the extent of the property being disposed of; (3) comprehend and appreciate the claims to which they ought to…
Rylands v Fletcher
A person who brings onto their land and collects and keeps there anything likely to do mischief if it escapes must keep it in at their peril, and if they fail to do so, they are prima facie answerable for all the damage…
Ramsgate Victoria Hotel Co v Montefiore
An offer lapses and is no longer open for acceptance after a reasonable time has elapsed. What constitutes a reasonable time is a question of fact depending on the nature of the subject matter and the circumstances of…
Scott v London and St Katherine Docks Co
Where an accident occurs that would not ordinarily happen without negligence, and the instrumentality causing the accident was under the defendant's control, the court may infer negligence (res ipsa loquitur). The…
Taylor v Caldwell
Where performance of a contract depends on the continued existence of a specific thing, and that thing is destroyed without fault of either party, the contract is discharged by frustration. Both parties are excused from…
Milroy v Lord
There are three and only three modes of making a valid voluntary settlement of property: (i) an outright transfer of property to the intended beneficiary; (ii) a declaration of trust in favour of the beneficiary by the…
Felthouse v Bindley
Silence, or a mere unexpressed mental assent, cannot amount to acceptance of an offer. An offeror is not entitled to stipulate that the offeree's silence will be treated as acceptance so as to impose a contract on them…
Tweddle v Atkinson
A person who is a stranger to a contract — that is, a person who is neither a party to the agreement nor has provided any consideration — cannot sue upon it to enforce rights purportedly created for their benefit, even…
Hadley v Baxendale
Damages recoverable for breach of contract are limited to losses that fall within one of two limbs: (1) those which arise naturally — i.e. according to the usual course of things — from the breach itself, the so-called…
Hochster v De La Tour
Where a party to a contract repudiates it before the time fixed for performance — by making clear they will not perform their obligations — the other party has an immediate right to treat the contract as at an end and…
Tulk v Moxhay
A restrictive covenant — a negative obligation burdening land (e.g. not to build) imposed by a vendor on a purchaser — will be enforced in equity against a subsequent purchaser of the burdened land who took it with…
Foss v Harbottle
Two fundamental rules govern litigation in respect of wrongs alleged to have been done to a company. First, the 'proper plaintiff rule': the only person who can sue for a wrong done to a company is the company itself…
Saunders v Vautier
A beneficiary who is of full age and capacity and is absolutely entitled to trust property can call upon the trustee to transfer the property to them, even if the trust instrument provides for a later date of…
Hyde v Wrench
A counter-offer destroys the original offer, which cannot thereafter be accepted. When an offeree responds with a counter-offer rather than an unconditional acceptance, the original offer is terminated and a new offer…
Knight v Knight
For a valid express trust, three certainties must be present: certainty of intention (words must show a clear intention to create a trust), certainty of subject matter (the trust property must be identifiable), and…
Adams v Lindsell
Where acceptance is sent by post, the contract is formed at the moment the letter of acceptance is posted, even if it never reaches the offeror. This is the 'postal rule'.
Stilk v Myrick
Performing an existing contractual duty owed to the promisor does not constitute good consideration for a fresh promise. Where a party merely does what they are already contractually bound to do, they provide nothing…
Carter v Boehm
Insurance is a contract upon speculation in which the special facts on which the contingent chance is computed most commonly lie in the knowledge of the insured alone, so good faith forbids either party from concealing…
Entick v Carrington
The executive branch of government has no power to interfere with the property or liberty of subjects except where it can point to clear legal authority, whether by Act of Parliament or established rule of common law. A…
Keech v Sandford
A trustee must not profit from their position of trust. Where a trustee takes a renewal of a lease that they hold on trust, the renewed lease is held on the same trust, even if the landlord had refused to renew the…
Pinnel's Case
The payment of a lesser sum of money in satisfaction of a greater sum of money cannot be any satisfaction for the whole debt. A creditor who promises to accept part payment in full discharge of the debt receives no…